Since the publication of Richard L. Bushman’s biography of Joseph Smith, Rough Stone Rolling in late September, I’ve attempted to track the book’s reception among critics. Every review I’ve come across thus far has credited Bushman with producing a balanced and well-researched and written examination of Joseph Smith’s life.
Martin Naparsteck’s review of Rough Stone Rolling for the Salt Lake Tribune, strikes a dissonant note, however. Naparsteck states that Bushman “attempts a biography of the founder of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints that meets the highest standards of professional historians and reflects his Mormon beliefs,” but “he gives us a tedious rendition of the known facts of Smith’s life, making one of the most interesting men in American religious history sound downright boring. The book requires inspired effort to read. He offers no new significant information and no new ways of viewing Smith.”
(more…)